Download The Powers of Philology: Dynamics of Textual Scholarship by Hans Ulrich Gumbrecht PDF

By Hans Ulrich Gumbrecht

Philology--the discovery, modifying, and presentation of ancient texts--was as soon as a firmly proven self-discipline that shaped the center research for college students throughout quite a lot of linguistic and literary fields. even if philology departments are gradually disappearing from modern academic institutions, during this ebook Hans Ulrich Gumbrecht demonstrates that the issues, criteria, and strategies of philology stay as very important as ever. for 2 and a part millennia philologists have considered themselves because the modest heirs and curators of the textual past's so much wonderful sessions, gathering and enhancing textual content fragments, historicizing them and including statement, and eventually instructing them to modern readers. Gumbrecht argues for a go back to this practice instead to a regularly free-floating textual interpretation and to the more moderen redefinition of literary reviews as "cultural experiences, " which dangers a lack of highbrow concentration. any such go back to philological center routines must consider the hidden hope that has encouraged philology for the reason that its Hellenistic beginnings: the will to make the previous current back by way of embodying it.

Show description

Read Online or Download The Powers of Philology: Dynamics of Textual Scholarship PDF

Best criticism & theory books

Abolishing Death: A Salvation Myth of Russian Twentieth-Century Literature

The belief of abolishing dying used to be some of the most influential myth-making ideas expressed in Russian literature from 1900 to 1930, in particular within the works of writers who attributed a "life-modeling" functionality to artwork. To them, paintings was once to create a lifestyles so aesthetically equipped and excellent that immortality will be an inevitable outcome.

A ''strange sapience'': the creative imagination of D.H. Lawrence

The purpose of this publication is twofold: to use the elemental insights of psychoanalytic notion to D. H. Lawrence and his works and to reach at a deeper appreciation of inventive approaches regularly. even though Lawrence himself used to be severe of psychoanalysis as a self-discipline, he however created a memorable physique of fiction that probed the fight of individuals attempting to in achieving wholeness within the face of constricting mental and environmental stumbling blocks.

Dostoevsky's religion

Any reader of Dostoevsky is straight away struck through the significance of faith in the international of his fiction. That stated, it's very tough to find a coherent set of spiritual ideals inside Dostoevsky’s works, and to argue that the author embraced those ideals. This ebook offers a trenchant reassessment of his faith through exhibiting how Dostoevsky used his writings because the car for an severe probing of the character of Christianity, of the person which means of trust and doubt, and of the issues of moral habit that come up from those questions.

Additional info for The Powers of Philology: Dynamics of Textual Scholarship

Example text

The text of the laws occupies less than half the surface of each page, and it is surrounded by a commentary presented in smaller print and structured by a quite complex system of internal cross-references. The pages of the Siete Partidas thus convey a strong impression of fullness, and one could ask whether they do not bring to its materialization a structural principle (or perhaps a structural paradox) that may be constitutive for the genre of commentary. " This structural principle will normally either produce an impression of fullness (in the case of a well-balanced distribution between text and commentary, such as the Siete 37 Partidas, one might say an impression of plenitude) or, if the margins are not filled up, an impres3.

The concepts of supplementarity and différance, a word invented by Derrida that puns on the distinction between the linguistic insistence on the reiteration of difference and this principle of deferral, have been present on the humanities scene only since the advent of the deconstructive movement. " The closeness between the host text and the parasitical deconstructive practice reaches its unbeatable fulfillment in the deconstructive claim of their inseparability. In other words, the self-unfolding deconstructive discourse will always claim to be both the primary text and its deconstruction.

17 Do we have to understand the concept of an "irrefutable reading" as converging with the ideal of exclusively text-based evidence? I do not completely rule out the possibility that de Man is pushing for a degree of rationality and conclusiveness in textual analysis that would verge on something like a "textual logic," with its own rules and techniques. Nevertheless, I think it is more likely that 30 de Man used the phrase to mean a reading maximally aware of its own conditions and limitations, a reading, therefore, that would be irrefutable because it would make claims only in relation to specific parameters.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.63 of 5 – based on 24 votes